Everyone loves the drama of an election night. Over the course of a few late hours, you undergo an emotional rollercoaster from exit polls to final results as you learn the fate of a given country for the next few years. Unfortunately for Politics Twitter, the US likely won’t have a conventional results night this year. Instead, it will have days- if not weeks- of results trickling in, and perhaps a nationwide series of violent protests by various far right extremist groups as an authoritarian president refuses to relinquish power.
Which I guess is drama of a different kind.
The Long Count

The first ingredient in this stew of a potential crisis is the nature of how votes will be cast and counted this year. Due to the ongoing pandemic, there has been a strong push by lawmakers- predominantly Democrats- to get people to vote by mail. This push is working; over a third of voters intend to vote by postal ballot this year (compared to 24% in 2016). This is going to have a substantial effect on the time it will take to count all the votes, with Federal Elections Commission officials warning the true result may take weeks to confirm.
The long count will likely exacerbate a phenomenon known as blue shift, which has emerged in recent years. Blue shift refers to the tendency of Democrats to do better in the final result of an election count than may be expected from the results at the early stages of the count. This happens because Democratic voters are more likely to use postal ballots and early voting systems, which take longer to count than votes at polling stations. Blue shift was notably visible during the 2018 midterms, with many in the media underestimating the extent to which Democrats had succeeded in bringing about a “blue wave” on election night. This trend is likely to be more extreme this year- in an August 2020 poll, 48% of self-declared Joe Biden voters said they intended to vote by mail, compared to 23% of Trump voters.
However this is likely too complicated and too inconvenient a phenomenon for the sitting president to understand.
“Rigged”

Trump has been putting in the groundwork to refuse an unfavourable election result for the past four years. During the second presidential debate in 2016, he declared he would keep everyone “in suspense” on a decision to accept a losing result. After the 2016 election, despite his win, he baselessly asserted that between three and five million votes for Clinton were cast illegally. He has spent the past few months attacking the integrity of postal voting, and at the Republican National Convention a few weeks ago he stated that the only way he would lose this election would be if it was rigged against him. All of this adds up to the very plausible scenario that Trump will reject a Biden victory, especially if Biden only pulls ahead in the days after the election as postal votes are counted.
It is unclear what would happen in such an unprecedented situation. Would Trump simply refuse to leave the White House in January? Would Republican congresspeople turn on the most popular figure in their party- the man who, at this point, defines what the GOP is? Would the result be brought to the Supreme Court? Would Nancy Pelosi actually do something?
While these scenarios would likely be dramatic and consequential, one can imagine the weight of the American political establishment could get Trump to vacate the presidency one way or another by Inauguration Day. What would not be resolved as easily is the reaction of some of Trump’s most ardent and dangerous supporters.
Nazis… I Hate These Guys

The Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) identified 576 “extreme antigovernment groups” active in the United States in 2019, with 181 of these being classified as militias- paramilitary groups aimed at resisting a government crackdown. Exact membership numbers are impossible to find, though total militia membership in the US likely ranges in the tens of thousands. It would be false to say all of these militias are made up entirely of Trump supporters. Indeed, there are small portions of the libertarian and sovereign citizen movements who support Black Lives Matter, for instance. However, the very purpose of a militia is to resist government overreach- and a deep state conspiracy to overrule an election result would certainly fall into that category.
On top of this, the SPLC has shown that militia membership spikes once Democrats are elected president as concerns arise that people’s guns will be taken away. It also doesn’t include the thousands of unaffiliated white nationalists, neo-Nazis, neo-Confederates, gun rights activists, Christian militants, and other far right extremists who support Trump and would inflict violence upon those who don’t.
Several flavours of far right extremism are primed and ready to intervene in the case of Trump refusing to accept a loss. The Oath Keepers are probably the largest militia in the US, and have been among the most vocal groups resisting a “Marxist” takeover. Consisting of current and former members of law enforcement and the military, they purport to have 30,00 members (though this is likely an exaggeration). Their stated goal is to fulfill their oath to defend the Constitution against all enemies, foreign and domestic and to not obey orders perceived as unconstitutional. If Biden is seen as an illegitimate president by the Oath Keepers, then any order he gives would be unconstitutional in their eyes. And this isn’t just speculation; the Oath Keepers- and their founder Stewart Rhodes- were banned from Twitter in the past week for violating Twitter’s terrorism and violent extremism policy. This was after they tweeted there would be “open warfare against the Marxist insurrectionists by election night, no matter what you do.” They have previously had armed presences at the Ferguson protests in 2015 and have been frequently seen this summer at Black Lives Matter protests across the US.
The Oath Keepers- and groups like them- additionally overlap hugely with right wing conspiracy theorists, such as the QAnon movement. QAnon, if you are unaware, refers to a complicated conspiracy theory regarding a secret ring of paedophiles who runs the US government, who are singularly being thwarted by Donald Trump. QAnon also runs into the “boogaloo” movement: the set of armed extremists currently preparing to fight on the side of racism in a second American Civil War.
It would be unrealistic to expect that the prospective crisis in the US will reach the heights that its instigators may hope for- there will not likely be a second civil war before January 2021. But equally it would be naive to expect this collection of violent extremists to passively accept a Biden victory- especially if Trump doesn’t. The far right held their rally in Charlottesville in response to their candidate winning. How many Charlottesvilles will happen when he doesn’t win? When the election is “stolen” from him?
When a clandestine ring of paedophiles uses the cover of a fake (but also Chinese plotted) pandemic to remove the people’s champion in favour of a socialist puppet, just what will the far right do to defend their republic?
Sources:
- https://www.splcenter.org/fighting-hate/extremist-files/ideology/antigovernment
- https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/2020-election-trump-biden-winner-results-when-delay-a9665141.html
- https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/elections/2020/08/18/election-2020-biden-voters-twice-likely-vote-mail-survey-finds/3394795001/
- https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/08/brace-blue-shift/615097/
- https://www.eac.gov/news/2017/06/29/newly-released-2016-election-administration-and-voting-survey-provides-snapshot
- https://www.engadget.com/twitter-the-oath-keepers-211426663.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAHKbf2HqstGkEHMAxO9Fu9Ylh7QwSNKy0xkP_FpClq7FajkNB0kP15fMailsuoNRtRxMrz4ozOLw427Bq5XzdAP-vCQoE4zuaSom9n9Z7QF_G-XtqhKFRgn68ALeTuCVTVQalIXaD_XYkldmpnkg15E6OZQfFOEytQRPn8FCzEo6